Top 12 Fantasy QB Rankings 2025: McCarthy Debates & Goff Slander
What’s up, Dudes fans! In this episode, the guys rank their top 12 fantasy football quarterbacks. The debate gets spicy right away—one host thinks rookie JJ McCarthy could be great with Justin Jefferson and Jordan Addison, but the others say “he can’t even throw!” They also talk about Justin Fields running wild in New York, and ask if they’re being too hard on Patrick Mahomes after finishing QB11 last year.
You’ll also hear about:
- Jared Goff’s chances to do it again
- Kyler Murray’s running skills
- Baker Mayfield’s ceiling
- Who’s better: Joe Burrow or Jalen Hurts?
They finish the episode with their “Mexican food Mount Rushmore”—from carne asada burritos to churros! A must-watch for fantasy football fans who want to know which QBs to draft or avoid this season.
Time stamps
00:00 Introduction and Episode Overview
00:38 Starting the QB Rankings Discussion
00:53 Debating JJ McCarthy's Ranking
03:59 Justin Fields' Fantasy Potential
10:18 Start, Bench, Cut: QB Edition
11:50 Brock Purdy's Fantasy Value
15:16 Justin Herbert and Dak Prescott Analysis
20:10 Patrick Mahomes' Fantasy Outlook
36:21 Debating Jared Goff's Fantasy Value
37:51 Bo Nix: Fantasy Potential and Real-Life Performance
39:20 Kyler Murray's Fantasy Outlook
42:34 Baker Mayfield's Fantasy Prospects
46:05 Comparing Joe Burrow and Jalen Hurts
52:03 Top Fantasy Quarterbacks: Rankings and Analysis
58:03 Mount Rushmore of Mexican Food
Connect with the Show
https://x.com/TFFDudes
https://www.instagram.com/tffdudes/
Watch the Dudes on Youtube at
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2JAx3YD3P-OJRiaqA7wSQw
Questions for the show
tffdudes@gmail.com
Watch the Dudes on Youtube at
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UC2JAx3YD3P-OJRiaqA7wSQw
Sponsors
Trophy Smack
www.trophysmack.com/dudes
Sleeper
www.sleeper.com
Dudes100 and they will match you $100